GMC brand mark

2017–2023 GMC Acadia · common problems & known faults

The 2nd-gen Acadia is a mid-size SUV; the shift-to-park glitch and 9-speed behaviour are the checks.

Compiled & reviewed by the VehicleFaults Research Team · last reviewed July 2026

Quick answer

The most commonly reported faults on the 2017–2023 GMC Acadia are 'Shift to Park' warning even when in park, 9-speed automatic shudder / hard shifts and AC condenser faults. 1 of the documented issues are rated high severity · inspect these first. Full inspection points, onset mileage and what to check are listed below.

Turn these known faults into a step-by-step viewing plan for this exact GMC Acadia · $9.

Build the inspection plan

Reliability snapshot

Based on the documented faults on this page for the GMC Acadia.

5.7/ 10
Mixed
Critical
0
High
1
Medium
5
Low
2

Guidance only · reflects reported patterns, not a specific car's condition.

Known faults to check

ElectricalHigh

'Shift to Park' warning even when in park.

Typically appears
Any
What to inspect
Confirm it shifts to park cleanly without a persistent warning.
TransmissionMedium

9-speed automatic shudder / hard shifts.

Typically appears
Any
What to inspect
Feel for shudder on light acceleration.

Turn these known faults into a step-by-step viewing plan for this exact GMC Acadia · $9.

Build the inspection plan
HVACMedium

AC condenser faults.

Typically appears
70,000+ miles
What to inspect
Confirm cold AC output.
ElectricalLow

Stabilitrak and infotainment glitches.

Typically appears
Age-related
What to inspect
Watch for warning messages and test the screen.
Engine/CoolingMedium

Cooling fans running constantly on high speed and temperature gauge reading cold (P0128 thermostat failure).

Typically appears
40,000-70,000 miles
What to inspect
Start the engine from cold and let it idle. Listen to see if the radiator fans immediately engage on maximum speed whilst the temperature gauge remains pinned at the bottom.
DrivetrainMedium

Juddering, binding, or a scrubbing sensation from the rear axle during tight turns on AWD models.

Typically appears
30,000-50,000 miles
What to inspect
Perform a tight figure-of-eight manoeuvre at low speed on the forecourt. Feel for driveline binding and listen for chatter or tyre scrubbing from the rear differential.
SuspensionLow

Clunking or popping noises from the front end when turning the steering wheel or traversing small bumps.

Typically appears
50,000-80,000 miles
What to inspect
Whilst stationary on the forecourt, rock the steering wheel vigorously lock-to-lock and listen for popping noises emanating from the front suspension turrets indicating worn strut top mounts.
Body/InteriorMedium

Water ingress into the cabin causing damp front carpets or water stains on the A-pillar headlining.

Typically appears
3-5 years
What to inspect
Press firmly into the front footwell carpets with your hand to check for dampness, and visually inspect the A-pillar fabric for brown water tide marks indicating blocked sunroof drains.

Inspecting a GMC Acadia?

Build a tickable plan for the viewing · where to look, what a bad result means and what to ask the seller. One-off price $9.

Build my inspection plan

Frequently asked questions

Is the Acadia reliable?

Average — the shift-to-park fault and transmission shudder are the common complaints.

What is the shift-to-park problem?

A faulty park sensor triggers a warning and can prevent restart; confirm it's resolved.

Which engine is best?

The 3.6 V6 is stronger than the 2.5 four; the 2.0T is a good middle ground.

Do the 3.6-litre V6 engines in this generation still suffer from timing chain stretch?

While earlier first-generation Acadias were notorious for timing chain failures, the second-generation 3.6-litre unit features an updated chain design and improved oiling. Failures are now rare, provided previous owners adhered to strict oil change intervals. Always check the service history for regular engine oil and filter replacements.

What is the maximum towing capacity for the second-generation Acadia?

The towing limit depends heavily on the engine and factory options. The 2.5-litre four-cylinder is restricted to a mere 454 kg, making it unsuitable for most caravans. However, models fitted with the 3.6-litre V6 and the factory towing package can safely pull up to 1,814 kg.

Does the twin-clutch AWD system require bespoke maintenance?

Yes, the advanced twin-clutch rear differential, typically found on AT4 and Denali trims, requires specific fluid changes to prevent clutch pack binding. The manufacturer mandates replacing the rear axle fluid every 45,000 miles under normal driving conditions. Ensure the correct specification of differential oil is used.

Sources & further reading

Faults are compiled from documented recalls, technical bulletins, owner reports and mechanic sources, then reviewed for accuracy. This is guidance only · not a substitute for a professional inspection.

Buying a GMC Acadia?

Build the plan